Phantom Blade Zero at 88: The Combat Is the Verdict, the Story Is the Caveat
Phantom Blade Zero launches tomorrow, October 29, on PlayStation 5 and PC, and it arrives with something most games never get: a consensus. The review embargo lifted on October 26, and critics landed in almost the same place. Metacritic sits at 88, from more than 30 critic reviews, with nearly all of them positive. OpenCritic's Top Critic Average is around 90, with the vast majority of critics recommending it. Aggregates move as more reviews land, so treat those numbers as a snapshot taken on launch week, not a final grade carved in stone. Even as a snapshot, the message is unusually clear.
The combat is the game. The story is the asterisk. Almost every review says some version of that sentence, and the scores line up behind it.
The scores, in one place
Here is the shape of the consensus, with the headline scores reported at embargo time and shortly after:
- IGN: 9 out of 10, calling it one of the best action games in a long time.
- Push Square: 9 out of 10. TheSixthAxis: 9 out of 10. GamingBolt: 9 out of 10.
- GamesRadar: 9 out of 10, calling it a Game of the Year contender.
- GameSpot: 8 out of 10. VGC: 4 out of 5.
- Wccftech and TheGamer: 10 out of 10, the latter its reviewer's first perfect score in seven years.
- Eurogamer: 3 out of 5, the notable dissent, praising the fluid combat while flagging balance and quality issues.
That spread is worth reading properly. An 88 built on a pile of 9s and one 3 is a different thing from an 88 built on a pile of 8s. The high scores are enthusiastic, not polite. The low score is not confused about what it likes. Both sides agree on the combat. They disagree on how much the rest of the game matters.
What the combat actually is
You play Soul, a warrior with only 66 days left to live, fighting through a dark wuxia world of assassins and world ending conspiracies. The combat system is built around deflecting and parrying, chained into fast, acrobatic exchanges, with a Sha-Chi gauge managing your most powerful options. The arsenal runs to more than 50 weapons, and reviewers consistently single out two things: how good the fighting feels moment to moment, and how memorable the boss encounters are.
That second point is doing a lot of work. A lot of action games have good combat in a hallway and then fall apart when a boss shows up. The Phantom Blade Zero reviews describe the opposite problem, if you can call it a problem: the bosses are so good that they set the bar for everything around them. GamesRadar's verdict calls out secret bosses and powerful weapons hidden in a richly designed world, and IGN's review describes the arcade combat and difficulty curve as exceptionally well tuned. When a reviewer calls a game spectacular and occasionally gloriously ridiculous, that is not a backhanded compliment. That is a reviewer having fun.

There is also a useful comparison hiding in the coverage. Phantom Blade Zero is the second major Chinese action game in as many years to break through globally after Black Myth: Wukong, and the two games make an interesting pair. Wukong built its combat around a staff, transformations, and boss spectacle. Phantom Blade Zero builds its combat around a sword, blocking, and parrying, and leans harder into acrobatics. Same ambition, different fighting philosophy. If Wukong proved that a Chinese studio could make a global action hit, Phantom Blade Zero is testing whether that success can become a pattern rather than a one off.
The caveat, stated honestly
Now the other half of the consensus, because it matters for anyone deciding whether to buy on day one. The recurring complaints are a safe, sometimes hard to follow story, linear levels with limited exploration, some invisible walls, and occasional performance dips. Eurogamer's mixed review is the sharpest version of this critique, but it is not alone: even the 9 out of 10 reviews tend to mention the story as the weakest element, not a strength.
GameSpot's review puts the split in the most quotable form: the combat is so good you stop caring that the story makes no sense. That is a fun line, and it is also a real buying signal. If you play action games for the story first, this consensus should slow you down. If you play them for the fighting, the same consensus should speed you up. A review roundup is only useful if it tells different players different things, and this one does.
There is a second, quieter caveat worth naming: length and structure. Reports around the embargo put roughly 30 to 35 hours to the final boss, with secret bosses and alternate ending content beyond that. That is a substantial game, but it is not an open world, and reviewers who went in expecting one came away noting the linearity. Set your expectations to a crafted action game with secrets tucked into its corners, not a map full of icons.
What to know before launch
The practical details, all confirmed ahead of launch. Platforms: PlayStation 5 and PC via Steam and Epic, on October 29. There is no PC date confusion here, and no Xbox or Switch version announced. Price: $59.99 for the Standard Edition, $69.99 for the Digital Deluxe Edition, which adds outfits, a digital artbook, and a digital soundtrack. Global unlock is 2 AM UTC on October 29, which means the evening of October 28 in the Americas. Clear some space before then: reports put the PlayStation 5 install at over 130 GB.
One more detail that says something about the studio: S-GAME has said no generative AI was used in the game's development, as reported by Push Square. In a year when that question follows every major release, an answer given before launch is worth noting, even if it is not a review score.
And the timing could hardly be busier. October 29 is a stacked day: Final Fantasy VII Remake Intergrade joins Game Pass, Mouthwashing lands on consoles, and The Wolf Among Us Remastered arrives, all on the same Thursday. Phantom Blade Zero is not launching into an empty week. It is launching into a fight for your evening, and it is doing it with an 88 behind it.
One last thing, and it is the number our bulletin led with today: an 88 that still only lands around the high 20s for the year tells you how stacked 2026 has been. Phantom Blade Zero did not walk into a weak year. It walked into a strong one and still stood out. That is the context the score deserves.
Images: S-GAME, official screenshots.
Watch the video version: GameNow TV News, Oct 28